A Critique of Dialogue in Philosophical Hermeneutics

A Critique of Dialogue in Philosophical Hermeneutics

by Hans-Herbert Kogler – [ Journal of Dialogue Studies, Vol 2 No 1 ]

Video

Abstract

The idea of dialogue occupies arguably the most central position in Hans-Georg Gadamer’s philosophical hermeneutics (Gadamer 1960/1989). Dialogue is here not understood merely as the conversation between two subjects about something of common interest in a shared medium of understanding, but rather as the foundational phenomenon within which objects and themes, subjects and perspectives, and common interest and shared understanding are grounded. The foundational character of dialogue derives from the fact that all experience is understood to be linguistically mediated, while language as a medium exists in its true and essential form as dialogue. The strongest support for this approach comes from a phenomenological perspective on understanding, i.e. on what really happens when we understand something, when we make sense of something by interpreting it. Bringing together the encompassing and foundational role of dialogue with its concrete origin in the act of interpretation will yield, as I will show, a post- metaphysical concept of understanding as dialogue. Gadamer’s own philosophical-hermeneutic conception of dialogue both suggests and yet misses its full articulation, as our analysis of the idea of dialogue in philosophical hermeneutics, the question of the metaphysical grounds of understanding in language, and the issue of the epistemological significance of dialogue will show.
Related Articles
The 30th Anniversary of a Grassroots Dialogue in Northern Ireland
Democracy, Dissent, and Dialogue in Contemporary India
Public Policy, Collaborative Governance, and Female Entrepreneurship in the Caribbean: A Critical Assessment
Rethinking Dialogic Narratives in Water Diplomacy
Cultures of Dialogue and Pro-democracy in Equatorial Guinea and Diaspora
The Case of the Popular University of Social Movements: Lessons on Dialogue From and For Humanisation and the Transformation of Institutions
Dialogues in Consensus-building for Governance
Book Review: Paul Weller, Fethullah Gülen’s Teaching and Practice: Inheritance, Context, and Interactive Development (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2022)
Hindus and Dialogue: Implications of using Dialogic Structure in Expressing Philosophy
Humanists and Dialogue: Why the Non-religious must be Included
Jews and Dialogue
Muslims and Dialogue: The Value of Inter-Convictional Approaches in ‘Coming to Common Terms’
Christians and Dialogue: An Opinion Piece
Dialogue Method: A Proposal to Foster Intra- and Inter-community Dialogic Engagement
A Place-based Approach to Online Dialogue: Appreciative Inquiry in Utrecht, the Netherlands during the Coronavirus Pandemic
Caring and Power-Sharing: How Dialogue Influences Community Sustainability
Curating Spaces of Hope: Exploring the Potential for Intra-Communities’ Dialogue (ICD) and Faith-Based Organisations, in a Post-COVID Society
The Buddhist Nuns and Dialogue in Wartime Myanmar: Understanding the ‘Banality of Othering’
Rethinking Dialogue Practices among Children: Philosophy for Children and Phenomenology as Approach towards Conflict Resolution in a Diverse Classroom
Virtual Dialogues: A Method to Deal with Polarisation in a Time of Social Isolation Caused by COVID-19
Online Peace-building Dialogue: Opportunities & Challenges Post-Covid-19 Pandemic Emergence
Dialogue in Lockdown: Online Dialogue and its Lessons Amidst Rising Popularism
Miscommunicating across Borders: Ethnographic Reflections on EU Techniques of ‘Better Communication’ from Brussels
Understanding the Psychological Mechanisms that Constrain the Transfer of Dialogue Effects
Dialogue and Peacebuilding in Colombia: A Dialogic and a Transformative Relationship
Aspects of Effective Dialogic Interventions
Dialogue and Environmental Education: Conflicts Between Marine Conservation and Fishing
‘Culture of Dialogue’ as a Decolonial Peace-Building Tool: The Case of Colombia
Hans-Georg Gadamer’s Truth and Method Revisited: On the Very Idea of a Fusion of Horizons in Intense, Asymmetric and Intractable Conflicts
Dialogue and the Cultural Other in Conflict Situations: An Augmented Understanding
Photovoice: A Focus on Dialogue, Young People, Peace and Change
Reflection: The Challenge and Power of Dialogue
Pedagogy of Care and Dialogue: A Theoretical Review of Approaches to Moral Education
‘Lived Faith’ as an Approach to Inter- Religious Dialogue – Designing for Discussion
Faith, Peace Building, and Intra-Community Dialogue in South Yorkshire, UK
Gadamer, Play, and Interreligious Dialogue as the Opening of Horizons
Philosophical Hermeneutics and Comparative Political Theory
Tribal Morality and the Ethical Other: The Tension Between Modern Moral Aspirations and Evolved Moral Dispositions
“Holding Oneself Open in a Conversation” – Gadamer’s Philosophical Hermeneutics and the Ethics of Dialogue
’Stir It Up’: Contestation and the Dialogue in the Artistic Practice of the Twin of Twins
Involving Disadvantaged People in Dialogue: Arguments and Examples from Mental Health Care
Civic Dialogue: Attending to Locality and Recovering Monologue
Integrity and Dialogue
Philosophy, Ethics and Dialogue
’Just Send Me Word’: the Promise of Dialogue
Bohmian Dialogue: a Critical Retrospective of Bohm’s Approach to Dialogue as a Practice of Collective Communication
The Dalai Lama’s Dialogues
Studying Dialogue - Some Reflections
On Dialogue Studies