Miscommunicating across Borders: Ethnographic Reflections on EU Techniques of ‘Better Communication’ from Brussels

Miscommunicating across Borders: Ethnographic Reflections on EU Techniques of ‘Better Communication’ from Brussels

by Seamus Montgomery – [ Journal of Dialogue Studies Vol 8 ]

Video

Abstract

Whether stemming from rising inequality, economic stagnation, or technological disruption, global processes of transformation are changing European societies. With distrust in EU institutions at an all-time low, a perceived absence of a European demos or polity is attributed in part to the nonexistence of a European public square, a forum for direct communication between EU institutions and EU citizens. So-called ‘hearts and minds strategies’, such as Citizens’ Dialogues and the European Citizens’ Initiative, aim to go beyond the rhetorics of convergence criteria, stability mechanisms, and bailout packages that dominate weekly news cycles. In contrast with liberalist discourses of idealisation and universalisation, a reactionary populism fetishises a return to an age when fiscal and migration policy were the sole province of national capitals. This paper critically analyses discourses surrounding ‘dialogue’ and ‘better communication’ inside the European Commission in Brussels, drawn from extensive ethnographic fieldwork carried out within its office spaces. Through participant-observation and in-person, semi-structured interviewing with civil servants, it explores the ways in which they seek to fill the dialogical spaces currently occupied by populist voices in order to reaffirm the legitimacy underpinning the existence of the EU and of a supranational, imagined community of Europeans who identify with and belong to it. Its findings suggest that the achievement of ‘better communication’ with citizens by the European Commission is made all the more intractable by its struggle to define an institutional European identity that is inclusive, coherent, persuasive and distinct.
Related Articles
The Buddhist Nuns and Dialogue in Wartime Myanmar: Understanding the ‘Banality of Othering’
Rethinking Dialogue Practices among Children: Philosophy for Children and Phenomenology as Approach towards Conflict Resolution in a Diverse Classroom
Virtual Dialogues: A Method to Deal with Polarisation in a Time of Social Isolation Caused by COVID-19
Online Peace-building Dialogue: Opportunities & Challenges Post-Covid-19 Pandemic Emergence
Dialogue in Lockdown: Online Dialogue and its Lessons Amidst Rising Popularism
Understanding the Psychological Mechanisms that Constrain the Transfer of Dialogue Effects
Dialogue and Peacebuilding in Colombia: A Dialogic and a Transformative Relationship
Aspects of Effective Dialogic Interventions
Dialogue and Environmental Education: Conflicts Between Marine Conservation and Fishing
‘Culture of Dialogue’ as a Decolonial Peace-Building Tool: The Case of Colombia
Dialogue and the Cultural Other in Conflict Situations: An Augmented Understanding
Photovoice: A Focus on Dialogue, Young People, Peace and Change
Reflection: The Challenge and Power of Dialogue
Pedagogy of Care and Dialogue: A Theoretical Review of Approaches to Moral Education
‘Lived Faith’ as an Approach to Inter- Religious Dialogue – Designing for Discussion
Faith, Peace Building, and Intra-Community Dialogue in South Yorkshire, UK
Philosophical Hermeneutics and Comparative Political Theory
Tribal Morality and the Ethical Other: The Tension Between Modern Moral Aspirations and Evolved Moral Dispositions
“Holding Oneself Open in a Conversation” – Gadamer’s Philosophical Hermeneutics and the Ethics of Dialogue
’Stir It Up’: Contestation and the Dialogue in the Artistic Practice of the Twin of Twins
Involving Disadvantaged People in Dialogue: Arguments and Examples from Mental Health Care
Civic Dialogue: Attending to Locality and Recovering Monologue
Integrity and Dialogue
A Critique of Dialogue in Philosophical Hermeneutics
’Just Send Me Word’: the Promise of Dialogue
Bohmian Dialogue: a Critical Retrospective of Bohm’s Approach to Dialogue as a Practice of Collective Communication
The Dalai Lama’s Dialogues
Studying Dialogue - Some Reflections
On Dialogue Studies