Philosophical Hermeneutics and Comparative Political Theory

Philosophical Hermeneutics and Comparative Political Theory

by Evgenia Ilieva – [ Journal of Dialogue Studies, Vol 3 No 2 ]

Video

Abstract

This paper examines Hans-Georg Gadamer’s philosophical hermeneutics and its appropriation by Fred Dallmayr as a powerful alternative to Orientalism and political theory’s parochialism. Drawing on Gadamer, a number of comparative political theorists similarly invoke the tropes of provocation, self-disruption, and self-dislocation to highlight the benefits that ensue from cross-cultural dialogue and the encounter with non-Western texts. But absent a more concrete theorisation of how dialogue may unsettle and disrupt our self-understandings, the repeated invocation of this trope remains just a phrase. The aim of this paper is to problematise the easy separation of dialogue from power that prevails in much CPT literature. To this end, I use Joshua Casteel’s account of the encounter between an interrogator and detainee in his Letters from Abu Ghraib as an example of the kind of transformative self-disruption that comparative political theorists invoke but do not theorise.
Related Articles
Reflection: The Challenge and Power of Dialogue
Pedagogy of Care and Dialogue: A Theoretical Review of Approaches to Moral Education
‘Lived Faith’ as an Approach to Inter- Religious Dialogue – Designing for Discussion
Faith, Peace Building, and Intra-Community Dialogue in South Yorkshire, UK
Tribal Morality and the Ethical Other: The Tension Between Modern Moral Aspirations and Evolved Moral Dispositions
“Holding Oneself Open in a Conversation” – Gadamer’s Philosophical Hermeneutics and the Ethics of Dialogue
’Stir It Up’: Contestation and the Dialogue in the Artistic Practice of the Twin of Twins
Involving Disadvantaged People in Dialogue: Arguments and Examples from Mental Health Care
Civic Dialogue: Attending to Locality and Recovering Monologue
Integrity and Dialogue
A Critique of Dialogue in Philosophical Hermeneutics
’Just Send Me Word’: the Promise of Dialogue
Bohmian Dialogue: a Critical Retrospective of Bohm’s Approach to Dialogue as a Practice of Collective Communication
The Dalai Lama’s Dialogues
Studying Dialogue - Some Reflections
On Dialogue Studies